Best Holster for the S&W M&P Shield 9mm: Summer Comfort + Top Alternatives

Shopping for the best holster for the S&W M&P Shield 9mm + .40 ? Start with leather that’s molded for the gun, carries comfortably all day, and draws clean. Below is our single best pick plus two use-case alternatives to keep things simple. If you’re specifically after a leather holster for the S&W M&P Shield 9mm, you’re in the right place. Ready to get yours? Shop our S&W M&P Shield Holsters

Best Leather Holster for S&W M&P Shield 9mm (Overall)

Summer Comfort™ IWB Holster — A proven, all-leather inside-the-waistband holster that disappears under a T-shirt yet stays stable thanks to dual snap loops. The hand-molded holster speeds your firing grip, the open-top design keeps the draw smooth, and the trim profile rides comfortably whether you’re seated or on your feet. For most owners, the Summer Comfort is the easiest path to everyday concealment with the M&P Shield.

Best Tuckable Option

Tuck-N-Go™ 2.0 — When you need a tucked shirt at the office or church, this minimalist steerhide IWB uses a tuckable clip to hide the pistol while maintaining access to a full firing grip. It repositions easily and stays comfortable through long days.

Best OWB Option

Combat Master™ Belt Holster — Prefer an outside-the-waistband holster? This classic pancake holster uses premium, hand-molded steerhide with full slide coverage to secure the Shield while keeping the draw fast and natural. Strong-side carry plus two belt slots hug the pistol tight to the body for discreet concealment under a light cover garment.

Fit notes

These leather holsters fit standard, non-light-bearing S&W M&P Shield 9 and Shield .40 (including many M2.0 variants). The Shield X has different dimensions and may require a different fit. Optics-equipped pistols may also need specific variants—check each product page’s current compatibility. To confirm your exact setup, try our Search by Gun tool.

Wrap-up: For most concealed carriers, the Summer Comfort remains the best holster for the S&W M&P Shield X. If you need a tuckable IWB for dress shirts, go Tuck-N-Go 2.0. Prefer OWB? Combat Master keeps things classic, secure, and fast.

Browse more: See all S&W M&P Shield holsters • Or use Search by Gun to verify your fit before you buy.

FAQs

Will these fit the M&P Shield .40 as well as the 9?
Yes—these leather fits are available for Shield 9 and Shield .40 (non-light-bearing). Always check the product page’s fit list for your exact model.

Do these leather holsters work with weapon lights?
Most traditional leather holsters are for non-light-bearing pistols. If you use a light, confirm compatibility on the product page before ordering.

Can I carry appendix with the Summer Comfort?
The Summer Comfort is easily converted to AIWB carry with our optional appendix IWB belt channel. Adjust position and belt tension for comfort and concealment.

What if I want a shoulder holster instead?
Shoulder carry is great for heavy layering or long drives. See our Shield category page for shoulder options if that’s your priority.